A Seahorse Wish | Oceanfront - Rental Property

Details At A Glance

  • 3536 Sandfiddler Rd
  • Property Type: House
  • Bedrooms: 9
  • Bathrooms: 9 full / 1 half
  • Occupancy: 27
  • Parking Spaces: 9
  • Square Footage: 6757

Check Availability

Starting at 4:00 PM
10:00am or earlier


If a magical creature like a seahorse can exist, so can a vacation rental that will push your expectations and leave you reeling in the sheer delight of this incredible home. This 9 bedroom home, A Seahorse Wish, is located directly on the ocean, and makes up one of three brand new luxury homes that can also be booked together for the ultimate beach stay.* Just like a seahorse, this three level home is unique and breathtaking with beautiful detailed artwork and painted furnishings depicting birds, sea creatures, and dreamy floral landscapes. Nautical accessories remind you of the mystery of the sea, with a well-planned floor plan ensuring your complete comfort.
A two-story "you can almost touch the ocean" gazebo, an in-ground pool with top-of-the-line patio and deck furniture, and a ten seat theater room are just a few of the remarkable treasures found at A Seahorse Wish. With bedrooms located on each level, this house is a great fit for families, couples and friends to share.
FIRST FLOOR: There are three bedrooms on the first level, beautifully tiled with gorgeous accent rugs throughout. One King Master Suite with full private bath, and ocean-facing deck access and two Queen Master Suite with full private bath that also offer deck access. The central Billiards room with a comfortable sitting area opens with a slider to the pool area, and has a flat screen TV to enjoy. A convenient wet bar and laundry room as well as a half bath service the 1st floor and pool area. Bring your favorite movies and Pop-Corn for a family movie night, while seated in the 10-seat Theater Room....what wonderful memories would be made at A Seahorse Wish while watching "Twenty Thousand Leagues' Under the Sea" or the original "Poseidon Adventure". If exercise is the one thing you can't leave behind while on vacation, work out on your schedule in the exercise room, equipped with an elliptical machine and treadmill, with a flat screen TV for keeping up with daily news.
SECOND FLOOR: Sparkling hardwood floors are the perfect background for the gorgeous view and furnishings that adorn this spacious middle level. The open dining and living areas greet you with comfortable fine furnishings and plenty of space to relax. The sitting area allows for conversation and warming up with the electric fireplace. A wet bar so graciously tends to your beverage selections, with a convenient half bath close by. The central area of the middle level boasts a circular table, perfect for a small gathering of friends to break away from the larger group, or perhaps could be the "children's eating area", it's so nice to have options! Ample dining tables are situated horizontally to the ocean, optimizing both the living space and the incredible ocean view. Imagine gathering with your family after a fine meal, cozied up on the living room couches, and listening to the crashing waves. The gorgeous "chef's dream kitchen" gives you two of almost everything....two dishwashers, two ranges, two refrigerators, and counter top seating for 5 along with an over-sized pantry for food storage. Top-of-the-line cabinets, appliances including a Keurig Coffee Machine and granite countertops are complimented by a well-stocked kitchen, with plenty of dishes, utensils and cookware to service the entire house. Sliding door access puts you directly on the east facing deck, which also supplies additional dining tables located under the "gazebo", a fantastic happy hour location or for reading the morning paper. If sunbathing is your favorite pastime, you will love the wrap-around deck to the south, which provides a sunny location away from the ocean breeze. There is one King Master Suite on the second floor, with a full master bath and deck access.
THIRD FLOOR: The third floor is home to 5 bedrooms, with a central library and card room with a small table and desk, the perfect way to get-away from the rest of your group if just for a quick read or game of cards. There are two King Master Suites with private baths, both with deck access and beautifully decorated with nautical furnishings and accents. There are two children's Bunk rooms, both also with private bath and two double/double bunks in each, appropriately furnished with your children and younger family members in mind. The fifth suite offers two Queen beds and a full private bath, also with access to the deck and the incredible views of the ocean. The second of two laundry rooms is located on this upper level, which is a great feature for a larger home shared by multiple families.

CAC, multiple flat screen TV's throughout, in ground pool and hot tub, two-story gazebo, theater room, elevator, fitness room, outdoor ping pong, corn hole, gas grills, electric fireplace available for off-season use from October-May. For handicap friendly features, please contact our office for specific details of this home. NO SMOKING.
A Seahorse Wish accepts reservations for full weeks only (Saturday to Saturday) May 5 to October 31st of each year."

Bed Sizes: Br1 - King, Br2 - King, Br3 - King, Br4 - King, Br5 - 2 Queens, Br6 - Queen, Br7 - Queen, Br8 - 2 Bunk Sets (Double/Double), Br9 - 2 Bunk Sets (Double/Double)


  • Block - 3500 Block
  • Parking Spaces - 9
  • Fireplace
  • Linen Package - Every Stay All Year
  • Pool - Dates - Homes 5/2-10/9/20
  • Exercise Room - Private
  • Keyless Entry
  • Internet
  • Pool Table
  • Elevator
  • Handicap Features
  • Pool - Outdoor
  • Theater Room
  • Ping Pong
  • Special Occasion
  • Hot Tub

2019 Rates

Pool Season 5/4/2019 to 10/11/2019 unless otherwise noted.
Pool Season 5/2/2020 to 10/9/2020 unless otherwise noted.
Start Date End Date Monthly Rate Weekly Average * 3 Night Rate
11/30/19 12/20/19 N/A $6,257.00 $3,417.00
12/21/19 01/03/20 N/A $6,257.00 N/A
* 3 nights stays are available only if there is a published rate for a specified time period and excludes Holiday weeks.

2020 Rates

Start Date End Date Monthly Rate Weekly Average * 3 Night Rate
01/04/20 03/27/20 N/A $6,357.00 $3,462.00
03/28/20 04/03/20 N/A $6,357.00 $3,462.00
04/04/20 04/10/20 N/A $6,357.00 $3,462.00
04/11/20 04/17/20 N/A $6,357.00 N/A
04/18/20 04/24/20 N/A $6,357.00 $3,462.00
04/25/20 05/01/20 N/A $6,357.00 $3,462.00
05/02/20 05/08/20 N/A $7,627.00 N/A
05/09/20 05/15/20 N/A $7,627.00 N/A
05/16/20 05/22/20 N/A $7,627.00 N/A
05/23/20 05/29/20 N/A $10,337.00 N/A
05/30/20 06/05/20 N/A $10,337.00 N/A
06/06/20 06/12/20 N/A $13,957.00 N/A
06/13/20 06/19/20 N/A $13,957.00 N/A
06/20/20 06/26/20 N/A $18,847.00 N/A
06/27/20 07/03/20 N/A $19,387.00 N/A
07/04/20 07/10/20 N/A $19,387.00 N/A
07/11/20 07/17/20 N/A $19,387.00 N/A
07/18/20 07/24/20 N/A $19,387.00 N/A
07/25/20 07/31/20 N/A $19,387.00 N/A
08/01/20 08/07/20 N/A $19,387.00 N/A
08/08/20 08/14/20 N/A $18,482.00 N/A
08/15/20 08/21/20 N/A $13,957.00 N/A
08/22/20 08/28/20 N/A $10,337.00 N/A
08/29/20 09/04/20 N/A $7,627.00 N/A
09/05/20 09/11/20 N/A $7,627.00 N/A
09/12/20 09/18/20 N/A $7,627.00 N/A
09/19/20 09/25/20 N/A $6,897.00 N/A
09/26/20 10/02/20 N/A $6,897.00 N/A
10/03/20 10/09/20 N/A $6,897.00 N/A
10/10/20 10/16/20 N/A $6,357.00 N/A
10/17/20 10/23/20 N/A $6,357.00 N/A
10/24/20 10/30/20 N/A $6,357.00 N/A
10/31/20 11/20/20 N/A $6,357.00 $3,462.00
11/21/20 11/27/20 N/A $6,357.00 N/A
11/28/20 12/18/20 N/A $6,357.00 $3,462.00
12/19/20 01/01/21 N/A $6,357.00 N/A
* 3 nights stays are available only if there is a published rate for a specified time period and excludes Holiday weeks.


Guest Reviews

Avg. Rating:
5/5 Rating
Mary H, Amherst, NY
Mary H, Amherst, NY writes:

The house was wonderful. Kitchen was well stocked with plenty of pots, pans dishes etc. Plenty of room for a group of 30. People who chose to stay at the pool could still see everyone at the ocean. Very nice. Would definitely stay again.

5/5 Rating
Kathleen Prestipino, Dunkirk, MD
Kathleen Prestipino, Dunkirk, MD writes:

We stayed at A Seahorse Wish 6/18-25. As a large family, we could not have been happier with this house. The house had absolutely everything we needed and more! Each room was decorated to perfection! The distance to the beach was ideal! We use both grills and loved the outdoor seating!! The movie theater room was a hit with the young and old. I would highly recommend A Seahorse Wish if your looking for a large house with an amazing view!

View All Reviews

All prices and/or descriptions are subject to change. Although every precaution is taken, errors in prices and/or descriptions do occur on our web site and in printing. We reserve the right to correct any such error.

Check Availability

Select your arrival and departure dates by clicking on the calendars below. The dates you select will be inserted to the right where you can get estimated rates and book the property.
Please call for reservations within 48 hours of arrival.

Select Arrival

Calculate Rates

Back to Top